A low offer is information rather than an insult. Ignoring it ends the only live conversation about your property and signals inflexibility to the next buyer. Counter with reasoning attached, move very little at first, negotiate terms as well as price, and respond promptly.
The instinct is to take it personally and refuse to respond. Both are expensive. Why a low offer is the cheapest information a listing produces, and how to answer it.
An offer arrives well below asking. The seller's first instinct is almost always to take it personally, and the second is to refuse to respond. Both are understandable and both are usually expensive.
A low offer is not an insult. It is information, and it is the only kind of information a listing produces that costs nothing to obtain.
In most cases a low offer is a buyer who wants the property and is opening where they think they can. That is not disrespect; it is negotiation, and at high price points where the buyer is often advised by people who negotiate professionally, it is close to standard practice.
Occasionally it means something else. A buyer testing whether the seller is under pressure. An agent obliged to submit an offer their client insisted on. Someone who has misread the market badly. These are distinguishable, and the way to distinguish them is to engage rather than to guess.
Sellers who refuse to respond to a low offer generally believe they are signaling strength. What they are actually doing is ending the only conversation currently happening about their property.
A buyer who opens low and receives silence moves on. A buyer who opens low and receives a firm, reasoned counter often moves considerably. The gap between an opening number and a closing number at this level is frequently large, and you cannot discover that without responding.
There is also a signal you may not intend. Silence reads as either an absent seller or an inflexible one, and both discourage the next buyer from bothering.
Counter, and counter with reasoning. A number alone invites another number. A number attached to three specific comparables, or to replacement cost, or to what is currently sitting unsold, is much harder to argue with and tells the buyer they are dealing with someone prepared.
Move very little, at first. A small counter from asking says the price is considered. A large one confirms the buyer's theory that there was air in the number, and invites them to keep pushing.
Address terms, not only price. Closing date, contingency periods, deposit size, whether they will accommodate a rent-back. Sellers frequently discover the buyer will pay more for terms that cost the seller nothing.
Answer promptly. Speed communicates confidence. Taking a week to reply suggests the offer required a great deal of thought.
There is a version worth naming. An offer at half of asking, from a buyer with no documented funds, with a long contingency period and no stated reasoning, is not an opening position. It is someone hoping for a distressed seller.
Even then, a short courteous counter at or near asking costs nothing and closes the matter cleanly. What it should never produce is an emotional reply, which can travel further than you would like in a small market.
If low offers are the only thing arriving, the offers are not the problem. Several low offers in succession are the market telling you something about the price, and that is worth hearing before the listing ages further.
One low offer is a negotiation. Three are a data point.
Almost always. Refusing to respond ends the only conversation currently happening about your property, and reads to buyers as either an absent or an inflexible seller. A firm reasoned counter often moves a buyer considerably.
Very little at first. A small counter says the price is considered. A large one confirms the buyer's theory that there was air in the number and invites further pushing.
A short courteous counter at or near asking closes it cleanly and costs nothing. What it should never produce is an emotional reply, which travels further than you would like in a small market.
Yes. Closing date, contingency periods, deposit size and rent-back arrangements all have value. Sellers frequently find a buyer will pay more in exchange for terms that cost the seller nothing.
Then the offers are not the problem. One low offer is a negotiation; three in succession are the market telling you something about the price, and it is worth hearing before the listing ages further.
A select network of the nation's most accomplished luxury real estate professionals.