Selling appreciated property and donating the proceeds means paying capital gains tax first, so the charity receives less. Giving the property directly to a qualified public charity generally allows a deduction at fair market value with no gain realized. Bargain sales, charitable remainder trusts and conservation easements offer alternatives.
Property is often the most appreciated asset a family holds and the least efficient to sell before giving. An overview of the structures owners use instead — direct gifts, bargain sales, charitable remainder trusts, conservation easements and donor-advised funds.
For many families, the most appreciated asset they hold is not a portfolio. It is property — a second home bought decades ago, a parcel of land inherited and never developed, a building that has quietly outrun every other investment on the balance sheet.
That creates a particular problem when the owner wants to give. Selling the asset and donating the proceeds is the obvious route, and it is usually the most expensive one. Capital gains tax is paid first, and the charity receives what is left. There are several structures that avoid that sequence, and most owners have never had them explained.
What follows is a general overview, not advice. Every one of these depends on specifics — how long the property has been held, whether it carries debt, what the owner needs from it in retirement, and which charity is receiving it. None should be attempted without a tax advisor and an estate attorney involved from the start.
When long-term appreciated real property is given directly to a qualified public charity, the donor can generally deduct its fair market value rather than what they originally paid, and the capital gain is never realized. Both benefits arrive at once, which is what makes the direct gift so much stronger than selling first.
The trade-off is a lower ceiling. Deductions for gifts of appreciated property to public charities are generally limited to 30% of adjusted gross income, against 60% for cash. Anything above the limit carries forward for up to five years.
Any non-cash gift above $5,000 requires a qualified appraisal and Form 8283. For real property this is not a formality — the appraisal is the number the deduction rests on, and the IRS examines it.
The simplest structure. Title transfers to the charity, which then sells the property itself. The donor takes the deduction and pays no capital gains tax.
Two things complicate it. Charities are not obliged to accept real estate, and many decline anything that carries environmental risk, unusual carrying costs or a difficult resale. And a mortgage changes the analysis entirely, because debt-encumbered property is treated as a part-sale rather than a pure gift.
The property is sold to the charity below market value. The difference between the sale price and the appraised value is treated as the charitable gift, and the basis is allocated proportionally between the sale portion and the gift portion.
This suits an owner who needs to recover some capital from the asset but not all of it — and it is the structure that mortgaged property most often falls into by default.
The property is transferred into an irrevocable trust, which sells it without immediate capital gains tax and pays the donor an income stream for life or for a fixed term of up to twenty years. Whatever remains at the end goes to the charity.
The donor takes a partial deduction at the outset, based on the projected remainder value. This is the structure for someone holding a highly appreciated, low-yielding asset who wants income from it without triggering the full gain in one year.
Mortgaged property and charitable remainder trusts do not mix well. Debt inside a trust raises self-dealing and unrelated business income problems that can undo the whole arrangement. Clear the debt first or choose a different structure.
Rather than giving the land, the owner gives up specific development rights over it, permanently. The deduction is based on the value of what was surrendered — the difference between the property's value unrestricted and its value with the easement in place.
The owner keeps the land and can still sell it, but the restriction runs with the title forever and binds every future owner. This appears throughout estate country in Virginia, Montana and the Hudson Valley, and buyers in those markets read easements carefully before making an offer.
One caution. Syndicated conservation easement transactions have drawn sustained IRS enforcement attention and are treated as listed transactions. A straightforward easement donated by the landowner is a well-established structure. A promoted deal offering an outsized deduction multiple is not the same thing.
Property is contributed to a sponsoring organization, which sells it and holds the proceeds in a fund. The donor takes the deduction in the year of the gift and recommends grants to charities over time.
This decouples the tax year from the giving decision, which matters in a year with an unusually large gain. Not every sponsor accepts real estate, so confirm capability before committing.
The most common and most costly error is donating too late. If a binding sale agreement is already in place when the property is transferred, the IRS can apply the assignment of income doctrine and treat the donor as having sold it themselves — leaving them with the capital gains tax and only a cash-equivalent deduction.
The gift has to be made before the sale is locked in. If a charitable outcome is part of the plan, it belongs in the conversation before the property goes to market, not during escrow.
Any of these begins with three questions: how long the property has been held and what its basis is, whether it carries debt, and what the owner needs the asset to do for them going forward. The structure follows from those answers rather than the other way round.
Speak with your tax advisor and estate attorney before making any commitment. Where a property sale is involved, we are glad to work alongside them on valuation and timing.
Because capital gains tax is paid first, and the charity receives what is left. Giving long-term appreciated property directly generally allows a deduction at fair market value while the gain is never realized.
Deductions for gifts of appreciated property to public charities are generally limited to 30% of adjusted gross income, against 60% for cash. Anything above the limit carries forward for up to five years.
Yes. Any non-cash gift above $5,000 requires a qualified appraisal and Form 8283. For real property this is not a formality — the appraisal is the number the deduction rests on, and the IRS examines it.
Debt changes the analysis significantly. Encumbered property is generally treated as a part-sale rather than a pure gift, and debt inside a charitable remainder trust raises self-dealing and unrelated business income problems. Clear the debt first or choose a different structure.
Before a binding sale agreement is in place. If the deal is already locked, the IRS can apply the assignment of income doctrine and treat you as having sold the property yourself — leaving you with the tax and only a cash-equivalent deduction.
A select network of the nation's most accomplished luxury real estate professionals.